Should Your Business Start a Customer Community? Here’s What You Need to Know

Listen, I’m not asking for a lot – just a clear answer on whether your business needs a customer community or not. But just like most strategic decisions in business, the answer isn’t a simple yes or no.

Let’s cut through the noise and figure out if a customer community is truly the right move for your business, or if you’re better off investing your resources elsewhere.

The Truth About Customer Communities

First things first – let’s get real about what a customer community actually is (and isn’t).

A customer community isn’t:

– Just another marketing tactic

– A quick way to boost sales

– Something you can set and forget

– A magic solution for customer engagement

A customer community is:

– A long-term investment in customer relationships

– A strategic platform for customer connection

– A commitment to ongoing engagement

– A valuable business asset (when done right)

Signs a Community Is RIGHT for Your Business

I don’t care what you’ve been told, but you don’t need a community just because other businesses have one. Here are the real indicators that your business is ready:

1. Your Customers Are Already Connecting

– They’re actively engaging with each other on your posts

– They’re asking to connect with other customers

– They’re sharing experiences and advice without prompting

– They’re forming unofficial groups around your brand

2. Your Business Model Benefits From Connection

– Your product or service has a learning curve

– Customers benefit from sharing experiences

– Success stories inspire and educate others

– Peer support enhances your offering

3. You Have the Right Foundation

– A loyal customer base exists

– Customers stay with you long-term

– Your brand values community and connection

– You have resources to dedicate to community building

Signs You Should Skip the Community (For Now)

Anyone else tired of seeing businesses launch communities they can’t maintain? Here are clear signs you should wait:

1. Your Business Isn’t Ready

– You’re still figuring out your core offering

– Customer retention is a major issue

– Your team is already stretched thin

– You’re struggling with basic customer service

2. Your Customers Aren’t Interested

– They prefer one-on-one interaction

– They’re not engaging with your current content

– They’re already overwhelmed with other communities

– They don’t see value in connecting with peers

3. The Numbers Don’t Make Sense

– Your customer lifetime value is relatively low

– You don’t have budget for community tools

– You can’t dedicate consistent time to management

– The ROI potential isn’t clear

The Hard Questions You Need to Ask

Before making your decision, answer these honestly:

1. Resource Reality Check

   – Can you dedicate 10-15 hours weekly to community management?

   – Do you have budget for community platforms and tools?

   – Is someone on your team passionate about community building?

2. Customer Value Check

   – Will a community genuinely enhance your customer experience?

   – Are your customers asking for more connection?

   – Does your offering benefit from shared experiences?

3. Business Alignment Check

   – Does a community support your long-term business goals?

   – Can you maintain engagement long-term?

   – Will this drive meaningful business results?

Making Your Decision

Here’s the bottom line: A customer community can be incredibly powerful for the right business at the right time. But it’s better to have no community than a neglected one.

You should start a community if:

– Your customers are actively seeking connection

– You have the resources to maintain it

– It aligns with your business model and goals

– You’re committed to long-term community building

You should wait if:

– Your resources are limited

– Your customers aren’t showing interest

– Your business isn’t stable enough yet

– You can’t commit to consistent engagement

What to Do Instead

If you’ve decided now isn’t the right time for a full community, consider these alternatives:

1. Start Smaller

   – Create engaging social media content

   – Host occasional virtual events

   – Foster connections in your existing channels

   – Build your email community first

2. Focus on Foundations

   – Strengthen your customer experience

   – Build your content strategy

   – Develop your brand voice

   – Grow your audience engagement

Remember: There’s no rule that says you need a community right now. The best businesses are built on strong foundations, not following trends.

Ready to make your decision? Take these insights, apply them to your unique situation, and trust your instincts. Your business (and your future community members) will thank you for taking the time to get this right.

Want to learn more about strategic business growth? Sign up for my newsletter where I share weekly insights on building a sustainable, profitable business – community or not.